by Mara Taylor
Donald Trump repeated a false and bizarre claim that Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, have abducted and eaten their neighbors’ pets. “In Springfield, they’re eating the dogs. The people that came in, they’re eating the cats. They’re eating the pets of the people that live there”, he said. Yes, he said it.
Trump’s claim that Haitian immigrants eat cats and other pets is not only factually incorrect but also disturbingly xenophobic. This statement, like many of Trump’s inflammatory remarks, taps into harmful stereotypes that dehumanize immigrant communities, reinforcing age-old racist tropes that paint certain groups as “uncivilized” or “dangerous.” In doing so, he stokes fear and division, exploiting ignorance for political gain.
To begin with, there is no credible evidence that Haitian immigrants, as a group, engage in the consumption of household pets. While food practices around the world vary greatly due to culture, tradition, and access to resources, Trump’s remark is a baseless caricature that overlooks the real struggles Haitian migrants face—often fleeing political instability, natural disasters, and extreme poverty. Reducing a complex people to demeaning tropes does not just dehumanize them; it distracts from the larger humanitarian issues at hand, such as the need for comprehensive immigration reform and support for vulnerable populations.
What’s particularly troubling about Trump’s statement is how it reinforces a pattern of racial othering. Immigrants, especially from non-European countries, have long been subject to claims that they are somehow incompatible with “American” norms—whether through exaggerated claims about crime, health, or, in this case, bizarre dietary habits. By singling out Haitians with such unfounded accusations, Trump is perpetuating a racist narrative that seeks to paint certain groups as “other,” using fear to foster an environment where exclusion and hostility toward immigrants are normalized.
“In barking about cats and dogs in Springfield, Trump, Vance and their right-wing supporters are spreading the same kind of anti-Haitian rhetoric that has sown a harmful distrust of Haitian migrants for over a century”, said Nathan H. Dize, assistant professor of French at Washington University in Saint Louis.
This rhetoric has dangerous consequences. By demonizing immigrants, it fuels prejudice and can lead to real-world violence and discrimination. History has repeatedly shown that words matter, especially from public figures. In a time when the U.S. is deeply divided, Trump’s comments fan the flames of racial resentment, rather than encourage empathy and understanding.
Ultimately, Trump’s claim does nothing to further meaningful dialogue on immigration or cultural diversity. Instead, it represents a cynical attempt to divide communities through misinformation. A serious conversation about immigration should focus on policies that address root causes of migration, foster integration, and support human dignity—not propagate offensive, baseless stereotypes.